Tuesday, June 17, 2008

This Article Was Censored In The Academy News

Talk about irony...here it is, in all its subversive glory:

I sit alone in a locker, pondering exactly what to write in this space. It is hard to write in such cramped quarters, but I must press on. I must finish this article, and then force it upon the next idiot who walks by (Hey!!) My voice will finally be heard after years of wandering the shadows, and being told to shut the hell up. That's right. I said “hell”. My editors have assured me that I will be allowed to use the word “hell.” (We did WHAT?), and use it I did. In fact, it might've been rather unnecessary to use it. But I used it anyway. Why? Because I can! Hooray for the First Amendment!

But then ask yourself, what exactly is the point of the First Amendment, which guarantees freedom of speech and freedom of the press?* Why do we need it in MTA, if some shady guy sitting in a locker will only use it as a cheap joke in a column he's writing? And if there is no point to the First Amendment, what point did I make by using the word “hell”? That would mean that my entire first paragraph is gone, and frankly, I worked hard on that.

I'd like to suggest that freedom of speech and freedom of press is not only valuable in the American system of democracy, but is also valuable within MTA. That's because freedom of speech guarantees the right of citizens to criticize their government in a constructive and respectful manner. The role of the media in an ideal society is to be the voice of the people, whose responsibility it is to tell the government what the people want and expect out of it, giving criticism whenever necessary. A free, eloquent, and active press has always been a hallmark of a democratic establishment, while a censored medium is a defining characteristic of a totalitarian body.

Why is this important in MTA? Since R' Gottleib took the helm 3 years ago, we've been promised a “new MTA,” and the efforts he has done to make it so have been commendable. However, there seems to be a lack of input on the students’ part as to the direction the school is headed. It seems to me that the administration follows its own path without allowing students to review and critique its policies. For this I fault both the administration and the students. The authorities that be have not shown much of a willingness to listen to the complaints of the students. They made a student council which has no voice, and has censored news articles that critiqued their actions. The students, for their part, have not made their issues known in a constructive manner; choosing to vandalize air conditioners and destroy the game room rather than address their issues.

This is why a free press in MTA is so vital. If the administration is so committed to the education and freedom of its students, it should allow grievances to be aired in student publications. Furthermore, the administration should actually read the articles, approach them with an open mind, and enact changes when necessary. On a student’s part, if you are upset with the school, don't break a window, regardless of how fun it might be. Write an article for The Academy News, write an article for Scope, post 99 Theses on the library door, whatever. Just make sure you are heard. For too long we've had school papers that barely come out. When they do, they rarely ever tackle actual issues, instead talking about a basketball game that happened six months ago. The school publications are there for you, the student, to have a voice in how the school is run. I urge you all to get up on your respective Soap Boxes and make your voices heard. If we are to have a school in which the everyone is happy, content, and opinionated, both the students and the administration need to work and not against each other.

Friday, May 16, 2008

Welcome To The Soapbox Unfettered

You may well be aware of the column being produced in MTA's Academy News, known as "The Soapbox". And you might enjoy it, and it may enlighten you otherwise meaningless existence. But then you may feel that there is more. And granted, there is. Maybe you should go outside, make some friends, and not be a total loser. But, if you're too lazy to do any of that, (I know I am), you can come to this blog, where all the random thoughts I have not contained within the pages of The Academy News shall be posted on this blog, allowing you to see the essays that weren't good enough to make into the real paper. However, let it be noted, that this blog is in no way affiliated with MTA, YUHSB, YU, or any institution for that matter. The views and opinions expressed therein do not reflect any of those institutions, and will in fact, probably contradict quite often. With that, I can continue without fear of getting disciplined.
Stay tuned for the upcoming Academy News, where my loyal representative Akiva Weisinger presents a piece that I gave to him.